When Manchester United turned to Ruben Amorim, it was seen as a bold step into a fresh direction. Young, tactically ambitious, and charismatic, he was meant to herald a new era at Old Trafford. But as the weeks have rolled by, his reign has sparked both optimism and doubt in equal measure. So, should United stick with Amorim or cut ties? Let’s weigh the arguments.

As always, if you have any thoughts on Manchester United this season or on the future of Ruben Amorim, get in touch with us by leaving a comment, following us on Bluesky (@NextGoalWinner) or Instagram (@NextGoalWin) and check out our YouTube channel (@NextGoalWinner).

Arguments For

Stability in the Dugout

United have been through too many managers in recent years, and another swift change could undo any semblance of continuity. Amorim, despite his struggles, represents a chance to build something over the long haul rather than chasing quick fixes.

Backed in the Market

The club has already invested heavily to bring in players that fit Amorim’s vision. Wholesale changes in the transfer market have been made with his influence front and centre, shipping out underperformers, signing prospects with potential, and laying the foundations for a squad that looks his own.

A Positive Personality

Amorim has injected charisma into the job. Unlike some of his predecessors who seemed weighed down by the pressure, Amorim carries himself with a natural energy that resonates with both fans and players. He has created a more vibrant atmosphere at Carrington and Old Trafford alike.

Improved Dressing Room Mood

Reports suggest the mood within the squad has lifted. Training sessions are sharper, the dressing room feels more united, and Amorim’s man-management has instilled belief where there was once only uncertainty.

Money Already Spent

Simply put, United have poured significant funds into moulding a squad in Amorim’s image. To discard him now would mean ripping up another project before it has a real chance to bed in.

Arguments Against

Results on the Pitch

All the charisma in the world counts for little when results don’t follow. Amorim’s United have yet to win back-to-back league games, an alarming statistic for a club of this stature.

Poor Win Percentage

The numbers don’t flatter him. His win rate is among the lowest of any United manager in the Premier League era, and it’s hard to defend a record that consistently leaves the team mid-table at best.

Lack of Tactical Flexibility

Amorim’s rigid approach has been a recurring complaint. His systems, so successful in Portugal, have often looked predictable and unsuited to the fast, physical demands of English football. When Plan A stalls, there rarely seems to be a Plan B.

Key Players Underperforming

Perhaps most damning is his failure to get the best out of his stars. Bruno Fernandes looks shackled, struggling to find space or rhythm in Amorim’s structure. Kobbie Mainoo, one of United’s brightest young hopes, has also found himself drifting in a midfield setup that doesn’t maximise his talents.

Verdict

The debate over Ruben Amorim boils down to patience versus pragmatism. Do United double down on their investment, hoping time allows Amorim’s ideas to flourish? Or do they acknowledge that results and performances simply aren’t good enough, and make yet another change?

For now, the jury remains firmly out, but in football, time is a luxury few managers are afforded, especially at Manchester United.